It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.
Read the literature review in your group’s article, and identify the themes it uses to frame its analysis. After you use this matrix to identify the themes discussed in the literature review, identify characteristics that you notice in the literature review, what makes it effective, what takes away from its effectiveness.
After completing the Individual Article Analysis Worksheet for each of your articles, use this Article Analysis Matrix to compile all of the information you have gathered. Use the Example Article Analysis Matrix below as a guide to get started.
Research Lab 3: Wednesday, 10/16/19
12:30-1:30pm (LL 134) with Professor Josefine Smith
5:30-6:30pm (LL 134) with Professor Christy Fic
Upon completion of this Research Lab, students will be able to:
Identify gaps in existing scholarship
Situate their research in the context of the current conversation on their research topic
Synthesize relevant scholarship
The Process of Writing a Literature Review
Mastering synthetic writing is key to a successful literature review. Use these resources to learn how to analyze the articles you want to use for your literature review, keep track of common themes using an article analysis matrix, and how to convert the notes in the analysis matrix into a piece of synthetic writing.
Think of working on your literature review as a multi-step process:
Identify a topic.
Find research articles on that topic.
Read and analyze each article.
Compare all of the themes addressed in the articles, as well as methodology/findings/limitations.
Use your notes from the article analysis matrix to decide how to organize your literature review.
Write your literature review by discussing one theme at a time--how is this theme covered in the literature?
Your literature review will also need an introduction and a conclusion. Some students like to start with the introduction, while others find it is easier to write the introduction after they have written the body of their literature review.
Don't forget to include References at the end of your paper (and to cite them properly within the text)!
Review step 4 "Write your Literature Review" for an explanation of how to write synthetically. Examine the "Literature review paragraph example" to learn how to deconstruct the elements of a literature review. Hover over each highlighted section for an explanation.
Examine the model literature review below (pgs 378-380).
Look for major ideas.
Determine how (and why) the author organized the literature review - thematically, chronologically, or methodologically.
Consider what rhetorical devices the author used to walk the reader through this section of their paper.
Ask the following questions as you read. Reflect on why the author made specific decisions in their writing.
Did the literature review...?
- big picture stuff -
engage with specialists in one discipline, or generalists in more than one discipline?
contain headings throughout to identify different themes/concepts?
- writing conventions -
flow in an engaging manner?
contain topic and transition sentences in each paragraph?
use appropriate citations?
put key words or concepts in italics/bold, making them easy to identify?
- analysis/evaluation -
describe the relationship of each work to the others under consideration, noting contradictory studies?
include major debates among scholars?
provide a new interpretation of the topic, or new solution to a problem?
trace the intellectual progression of the field, or reveal a new trend in the field?
highlight an aspect of the field that is missing?
discuss seminal works (influential studies that changed the direction of the field)?
explain how the existing literature intersects with their project, and/or how their project complements the existing literature?